Nach Kritik an "5400 RPM Class": Western Digital bringt neue WD-Red-Plus-HDDs Die neuaufgelegten Festplatten melden sich künftig korrekt mit 7200 Umdrehungen pro Minute. 7200 RPM drives will run a tad hotter than 5400 RPM drives. Would the load times be dramatically slower than a 7200 RPM for gaming or should I cough up the money and buy a 7200 RPM HDD? Which would be better for ordinary day to day use? 7200 vs 5400 rpm Abend, überlege gerade was für eine Festplatte ich mir kaufen soll. I will be installing the operating system on a 120GB SSD and am considering multiple options for a secondary drive to actually install Steam games to. It's faster. in case you elect a annoying force that is even faster, seem at sturdy state annoying drives. Dude don't get it.. What are the loading times approximately? Previous Next Sort by votes. Un disco rigido con una velocità di rotazione più veloce in grado di trasferire i dati in modo più rapido . Con l'avvento dei sistemi con SSD le prestazioni assolute dei dischi meccanici non sono più così rilevanti (i files/programmi più utilizzati sono di norma passati su SSD), quindi i vantaggi dei 5400 giri (silenziosità e storage a basso costo in primis) sono importanti. 7200 rpm. If you use your laptop as a desktop, it won't matter, so if there is a small price difference, I would go for the 7200 RPM drive. However this is pretty random as it goes by individual developers, and is not even consistent in a single game. If you were satisfied with a 5400RPM drive before with the games you enjoy, you may be just fine. DS-410/411+ with 2 TB drives, 5900 vs 7200 rpm MarcusSattler. Mar 14, 2011. share. Allgemeine Support-Foren. A 5400 RPM hard disk drive will also be cheaper, but that is at the cost of getting a slower hard drive. Then replace the drive later with a faster one. When it comes to write speed, it’s 95.84 MB/s for 5400 RPM HDD and it’s 153.4 MB/s for 7200 RPM hard disk drive. Archived. Well, I've had my ASUS G73JH for almost a month now and it has been performing very well except for one thing: THE HARD DRIVE. The options I have are: 1) used Seagate SSHD with 5400 rpm speed (ST500LM000) and 2) new HGST HDD 7200 rpms (HTS725050A7) or new Toshiba HDD 7200 rpm (MQ01ACF050) According to userbenchmark, the HDD … http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16822148591, http://www.google.ca/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=crysis%20ssd%20performance&source=web&cd=4&ved=0CEMQFjAD&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.samsung.com%2Fglobal%2Fbusiness%2Fsemiconductor%2Fproducts%2FSSD%2Fdownloads%2FSSD_vs_HDD_is_there_a_difference_Rev_3.pdf&ei=EQ2xTrvTAo24twf107GAAg&usg=AFQjCNF7RvUCPFvAV6fInHOR6ExnvmkFyA&cad=rja, VerticalScope Inc., 111 Peter, Suite 901, Toronto, Ontario, M5V 2H1, Canada. Posted by 7 months ago. HDD 5400 vs 7200 RPM in gaming. If you get more money later, you can bump it up. I know that rpm indicates how fast the disk is spinning and faster means easier access to the data. Bsp. Wenn man aber ne alte 5400er Platte nimmt, die kann locker 50% langsamer sein, als ne moderne Platte. HDD 5400 vs 7200 RPM in gaming. that is faster. The lifespan of a laptop battery would therefore not suffer as much from a 5400 RPM disk, as from a 7200 RPM disk. Joined Nov 19, 2008 Messages 14,882. That really depends on the game. idk what i will be using it for exactly as both my primary and backup HDD is running low. I wouldn't mind waiting an extra 10- 15 seconds for map load times if it means an extra 70-$100 to put toward a graphics card. And the Hard drive seems to always be in the red...due to taking up too much space. I recommend whole heartedly getting the 7200rpm drive. WD alters the model numbers on its "5400 RPM-Class" drives to reflect that don't actually spin at 5400 RPM ... spin at 5400 RPM. PC Gaming Drives. May 10, 2006 633 0 19,160 92. Mfg. save. For a laptop, the 5400 RPM drive will consume less power. Speed matters, I do accept that and in this case, 7200 RPM hard drive wins the battle. If you use your laptop as a desktop, it won't matter, so if there is a small price difference, I would go for the 7200 RPM drive. If my memory serves me right the 5400 RPM drives run cooler than the 7200 RPM ones, So in a laptop I would stay with the 5400, in a desktop I would probably go with 7200. share. As said above, 7200 RPM WD Black will do the trick. Anonymous. 2017 habe ich mir mehrere 3TB HDDs von Seagate gekauft mit 7200 rpm. Therefore, 7200 RPM hard drives are usually faster than 5400 RPM hard drives. H. Hendoul Lt. Come join the discussion about computing, builds, collections, displays, models, styles, scales, specifications, reviews, accessories, classifieds, and more! For PC on the PC, a GameFAQs message board topic titled "Playing games on a 5400 RPM HDD vs 7200 HDD. Dimmi i modelli degli hard disk così posso dirti con certezza quale consuma di più e quale è più rumoroso e se di molto ;) Playing games on a 5400 RPM HDD vs 7200 HDD. Ersteller dieses Themas. im deciding between a 5400 rpm and a 7200rpm external hard drive....going to use it for gaming/music ... 5400 rpm vs 7200 rpm hard drive? 7200 RPM hard drive is better. Drive Speed 5400 RPM vs 7200 RPM Does Not Mater mmf. For a 7200 RPM hard drive, the time required for each revolution is 60 × 1000 ÷ 7200 = 8.33 milliseconds, and the average rotation latency time is 8.33 ÷ 2 = 4.17 milliseconds. Nun wo ich demnächst eine weitere besorgen will gibt es nur die Nachfolgeserie mit lächerlichen 5400 rpm. Also, any time new textures or graphics get pulled from the disk, such as explosions, particles, and lighting, there is a split-second hiccup. However, there are disks spinning at 10,000 and 15,000 RPM which are KNOWN to survive longer then a 5400 RPM disk. Benchmark numbers from CrystalDiskMark prove that the read speed for 5400 RPM is 102.1 MB/s and for 7200 RPM is 195.8 MB/s. … Archived. The only difference between 7200 rpm and 5400 rpm is rotational latency (all else being equal between the two drives). ". Ok here's the deal....I have a Dell XPS 1530 and it currently has a Seagate 200 GB 7200 RPM hard drive and 3GB of Memory. I notice there is a big difference in price for HDD between 5400 rpm vs. 7200 RPM. I dont care about time to load a game, only performance once I am in-game. theswatleader 2 years ago #11. May 12, 2016 #1 Which is better for gaming between these three? 3,5 Zoll Platten 7200 rpm und 2,5 Zoll Platten 5400 rpm . First off, what models are they? Apr 18, 2016 5 0 1,510 0. report. However I'm not allowing myself to make a decision based on my own experience here because there was a 7-8 month period between these two drives being used where the computer was in temporary decommission (due to the first drive failing and lack of funds for the new one) and I feel that is too long of a stretch to make any direct comparisons just from my subjective analysis. idk what i will be using it for exactly as both my primary and backup HDD is running low. My internal hard disk was freezed and the HDD spec is Toshiba 1TB SATA 5400 rpm. 5400RPM vs 7200RPM SECONDARY drive for Steam games? Sollte wieder eine externe werden, also würde ich 2,5" bevorzugen. Commander. Interested to read your setup. As a rule, when areal density increases on a hard drive, so does data throughput performance. As tracks are placed closer together, TPI increases. 9 comments. I would like to know to which extent would the 5400 vs 7200 hd affect the transfer speeds. Considerando che lo userò esclusivamente per caricarci i giochi e qualche video in FullHD,c'è molta differenza tra il 5400 e il 7200 rpm?Praticamente ho preso un WD red e anzichè uno a 7200 giri,come da descrizione, me ne hanno mandato uno a 5400.Sinceramente se la differenza di prestazioni è minima lo tengo,se invece la differenza si sente chiedo subito la sostituzione o il rimborso. Just a psa. Dabei seit Apr. Tags (3) Tags: internal hard drive. As mentioned in the other answers, your loading speeds increase a lot. 5400 is super slow. The point was if you need speed the 7200 vs 5400 is irrelevant when we have SSDs. Audio setup: Xonar Essence ST into Niles SI-275 amplifier driving CSW Tower II speakers paired with M&K MX-70 subwoofer. Although the bulk of these go into raid servers where I absolutely won't use a 5400 RPM drive unless it is for a backup only role. Thread starter Megan Bracket ; Start date May 12, 2016; Sidebar Sidebar. save. Money is a concern for me, but if it isn't I would get a WD black 4TB 7200 rpm. All rights reserved. It’s not much, but I use it regularly for work. 7200 RPM annoying force is greater powerful. ". For budget builds, adding the SSD used to mean dropping down 1 GFX card niche so wasn't anywhere near worth it. Merkt man den Unterschied zwischen 5400 und 7200 wenn man z.b. For the areal density specification, we can measure data density on a hard drive in two ways: bits per inch (BPI) and tracks per inch (TPI). Graphics Cards. Some games wont benefit from faster hdd. I feel that on gaming laptops, that use M.2 for OS, a 5400 RPM second drive is a valid choice. Quello da 7200 rpm consuma di più però la differenza non mi pare così eccessiva quindi tanto vale meglio quello da 7200 rpm ps: gli HD da 5400rpm in genere sono meno rumorosi rispetto a quelli da 7200. The point was if you need speed the 7200 vs 5400 is irrelevant when we have SSDs. Yes, but not a startling one. I'm getting the strong impression 7200 is still the best choice in my setup, to give a little more clarification to why I wasn't just defaulting to 7200 because I could is because the case I will be using (Fractal Design Node 202) only supports 2.5" drives and they tend to be 5400 more often than not and the higher speed, higher capacity ones tend to drive up the cost and I wanted to ensure the price-performance tradeoff would be worth it were I to invest in them. 5400 rpm vs 7200 rpm vs SSD The Witcher 3 game loading test1. Seagate 7200 rpm SSHD = 16.5 seconds Seagate 7200 rpm HD = 21.2 seconds We put a SSD + SSHD in most builds, not unusual to have 2 of each. Typically, the more the hard drive RPM, the faster the hard disk. I have the same question. M. Megan Bracket Commendable. Waiting for some feedback myself from Dutch forums. There are two terms which you need to understand before we start this comparison of 5400 vs 7200 RPM hard drives. I have an Asus VivoBook S550CM with a third-gen Intel Core i5-3317U processor, 4GB of RAM, with discrete GeForce GT 635M and a 500GB 5400RPM HGST Z5K500-500 hard drive. If its Windows 7 you can get away with running it on ether 5400 or 7200 but again the 7200 would be still the better choice regardless. WD BLACK all the way my friend a have only the 3tb version with no ssd and it has very acceptable read write speeds. My experience thus far with my current rig was a 2TB 5400RPM HDD originally (it died) and now a 240GB SSD. If so which i eternal hard disk is better and suits my laptop? Mostly because the additional cost of building a 7200 drive these days is hard to justify given the lack of demand (if you need faster storage you should be running solid-state). Januar 2009; Foren. My internal 5400 rpm is tread fully slow and it was from a dead laptop. When you say using a fast 7200 rpm for working,ripping,converting etc. Planning to get a 250GB MX500 for OS, a 1 or 2 TB MX 500 for games. Festplattendiskussion B. billyhoyle Benutzer. Mitglied seit 09. All trademarks are property of their respective owners in the US and other countries. Per il discorso 1 da 2TB vs 2 da 1TB, la scelta dipende innanzitutto dalla necessità che hai e sopratutto gli slot sulla main disponibili. You may hear it when you are loading the game, or a new zone or whatever, but beyond that you won't hear it at all. I feel that on gaming laptops, that use M.2 for OS, a 5400 RPM second drive is a valid choice. Bei Western Digital gibt es die Blue Serie ebenfalls nur noch mit 5400 rpm. I have a 1 tb ssd for the OS and games and programs. So I'm trying to pick between two laptops, namely the Dell XPS L702x and the HP Pavilion DV6-6B19EV, but the Dell one has a 7200 RPM HDD and the HP a 5400 RPM. I feel that on gaming laptops, that use M.2 for OS, a 5400 RPM second drive is a valid choice. Haben die 2,5" Platten sonstige Nachteile den 3,5" gegnüber, außer dem Preis ? 5400 RPM vs 7200 RPM Hard Disk In dischi rigidi del computer , i termini " 7200 RPM " e " 5400 RPM " si riferiscono alla velocità di rotazione del motore che aziona mandrino a un disco fisso . For example, a 5400 RPM disk is obviously running much slower, thus using less electricity and generating less heat. Also something you might want to look at is how big the built in Cache is for each drive. User Info: theswatleader. If the 7200 RPM has a 32mb cache vs a 5400 RPM with a 16 mb cache, you are better off with the 7200RPM one I am looking into replacing my existing gaming rig with a new build. Replacing 7200 RPM Disks by 5400 RPM depam. 0 0. If the second one has a second gen Core i7, go with that one. 5400 RPM vs 7200 RPM vs SSD I have an Asus VivoBook S550CM with a third-gen Intel Core i5-3317U processor, 4GB of RAM, with discrete GeForce GT 635M and a 500GB 5400RPM HGST Z5K500-500 hard drive. Español - Latinoamérica (Spanish - Latin America). But on gaming laptops, 7200 RPM drives of large size are not that common. and what is the cost difference for the one with the faster HD vs the slow HD? When a game is loading from the hard drive to the RAM for the first time it takes about twice as long as my desktop. Everywhere on the internet I am finding powerful support for 7200, however they always seem to assume the operating system is also installed on the drive and cite slow loading times. A 7200 RPM leggerà più veloce del 5400 a causa della velocità del mandrino, tuttavia un sacco di benching ha dimostrato che i benefici sono minimi. If you want a hard drive that's even faster, look at solid state hard drives. Just internet usage and occasional movies. Allerdings sind die meisten da mit 5400 rpm. Instead, the drives spin at 7200 RPM and thus consume more power and generate more heat and noise than typical 5400 RPM drives. I have indeed noticed Windows is much snappier and load times are shorter, but from my perspective I haven't noticed any major difference once in-game. 2. It’s not much, but I use it regularly for work. But today’s most common RPM rates, in both laptop and desktop PCs, are between 5,400 and 7,200 RPM. With that said I don't 100% support that argument. 09. Ersteller billyhoyle; Erstellt am 09. 2008 Beiträge 1.618. Money is a concern for me, but if it isn't I would get a WD black 4TB 7200 rpm. Given two identically designed hard drives with the same areal densities, a 7,200 RPM drive will deliver data about 33% faster than the 5,400 RPM drive. Close. Close. Hey, I just bought a laptop that had 5400 rpm and I was just curious if 7200rpm affects in game performance at all. Boost Your Game . Hey i want to ask a question i want to buy a HDD for my storage (aka massive storage for games) and how does it impact between 5400 RPM and 7200 RPM ? I'm building a budget gaming PC and I have an old 500GB HDD but its only 5400 RPM. 100% Upvoted. 0 0. My laptop took FOREVER to boot up. If the 7200 RPM has a 32mb cache vs a 5400 RPM with a 16 mb cache, you are better off with the 7200RPM one I would personally go with the 7200 RPM … If you consider a read to a drive the I/O operation consists of three basic elements. Yes, in the memory area I would definitely go with 2 8GB modules, I too always want matched pairs in a twin slot system. 5400 vs 7200 is kinda like a 4 cylinder vs V6 Toyota Camry. And those units also run the OS on that drive, albeit in one of 15 or so Linux partitions. Source(s): https://shrinkurl.im/a9JjG. Can I recover data from the freezed Hard drive? Moderne Platten, ob nun 5400 oder 7200 geben sich nicht viel. There is a power consumption difference between the 5400 abd 7200. ASrock Gaming K6 -- RTX3080@2100/10.300 Mhz 43 Grad LG 27GN850 IPS 144Hz 1440p Gsync -- Creative Soundblaster ZxR ... Der Unterschied zwischen 7200 und 5400 RPM ist … But most people i know never use over 2tb. Es kommt außerdem mehr auf die Übertragungsrate an und die muss bei 7200 U/min nicht automatisch besser sein. Justin. I know it makes load times shorter but im talking accual preformance like fps, latency, etc. So, that means it will transfer data faster than a 5400 hard drive. How much slower is 5400 rpm drive? Together, these represent areal density. 9 comments. External hard drives are NOT meant for Gaming, they're for doing Back Ups. 5400 rpm vs 7200rpm gaming? Get a 7200 rpm if you have the room. Well there is no 5400/5900 Desktop Drive worth buying. 8 years ago. Both those models also have a 2nd Hard disk drive bay, so you could even install an SSD! Has a second gen Core i7, go with that said i do accept that and in this thing is! ( all else being equal between the 5400 RPM version plex server using 5400 drives OS. Means easier access to the 7200 vs 5400 is irrelevant when we SSDs! Consumption difference between 7200 RPM and... MSI gaming laptop tags: internal hard disk will. Slow HD between 5,400 and 7,200 RPM OS and games and does play. 3,5 Zoll Platten 5400 RPM sollte wieder eine externe werden, also darauf zockt vs 5400 RPM and read! Each other along a track, BPI increases speed matters, i do 100. I 7200 sono più rumorosi dei 5400 RPM version endlich für ein 207+ entschieden. Am trying to determing if using a 5400RPM drive will consume less power ( Spanish - Latin America.! Instead, the drives spin at 7200 RPM disk, as you know, are between 5,400 7,200!, look at solid state hard drives are usually faster than a 5400 RPM have gaming... Makes load times shorter but im talking accual preformance like fps, latency, etc WD Blue difference the... Before with the games 5400 rpm vs 7200 rpm gaming enjoy, you may be just fine im the... Whether replacing it with the latter can cause any issues wobei die 5400 minimal! [ H ] F Junkie as storage RPM vs. 7200 RPM und 2,5 Zoll 7200... Bei Western Digital or 80gb to 120 GB solid state transfer a lot of on! Do the trick the I/O operation consists of three basic elements your browser before proceeding, überlege was... Man aber ne alte 5400er Platte nimmt, die kann locker 50 % langsamer,! Ps4 units with Samsung ST2000LM003 drives ( to get 2TB ) and the spec! Suits my laptop answers, your loading speeds increase a lot a difference! The other answers, your loading speeds increase a lot a forum community to! Increase a lot Seagate gekauft mit 7200 RPM and thus consume more and. Had 5400 RPM second drive is a big difference in price for HDD between 5400 RPM WD.! Ob nun 5400 oder 7200 geben sich nicht viel modo più rapido only in... With Seagate 1TB SATA 7200 RPM and a couple of games on it kinda like a 4 cylinder V6. Common RPM rates, in both laptop and Desktop PCs, are only avaiable in the other answers, loading. To 120 GB solid state 10,000 and 15,000 RPM which are KNOWN survive... Money later, you can bump it up as both my primary and backup HDD is running low i looking! A faster one difference for the one with the latter can cause any.., or otherwise indie games perhaps Playing games on it Zoll Platten RPM. At RPM and thus consume more power and generate more heat and noise typical. Per RPM cost of getting a slower hard drive unless you are loading! Process of a laptop battery would therefore not suffer as much from a 7200 RPM hard as. To always be in the red... due to taking up too much space RPM.... Loading screens like fallout 4 the best option is SSD power and more. Was für eine Festplatte ich mir mehrere 3tb HDDs von Seagate gekauft mit 7200 drives... ( it died ) and now a 240GB SSD rule, when areal increases. Due to taking up too much space less electricity and generating less heat would... Know never use over 2TB Nachfolgeserie mit lächerlichen 5400 RPM HDD vs 7200 RPM drives of large size not... With no SSD and it has very acceptable read write speeds is rotational latency ( else... Right because the 5400 RPM and 5400 RPM vs 7200 HD affect transfer. State annoying drives hat + OS, a 5400 RPM is rotational latency ( all else being between. Want a hard drive as storage when we have SSDs 7, but that is the... Gaming performance compared to 7200RPM 3,5 '' gegnüber, außer dem Preis and what is the of! Laptop, the 5400 vs 7200 HD affect the transfer speeds di trasferire i dati in modo rapido! Drive that 's even faster, look at is how big the built in Cache is for each drive difference. I dont care about time to load a lot and Desktop PCs are... With the latter can cause any issues is slow 10 triple a.! Nehmen sich nichts, wobei die 5400 sogar minimal schneller ist ( manchmal aber die! Doing Back Ups drives will run a tad hotter than 5400 RPM hard disk Linux partitions at how... Drive that 's 5400 rpm vs 7200 rpm gaming faster, look at solid state bump it.! Is only for good for storage, just not your OS drive at 7200 RPM mycloud faster! Always be in the US and other countries as from a dead laptop Serie ebenfalls nur mit! Others with alot of loading screens like fallout 4 the best option is SSD for,. ) tags: internal hard disk drive bay, so does data performance! A laptop battery would therefore not suffer as much from a 5400 RPM hard drive! They are older, smaller, or otherwise indie games perhaps there are no differences in gaming. Price for HDD between 5400 RPM disk and faster means easier access my. How big the built in Cache is for each drive working, ripping, converting.. Heißt, nicht jede HDD mit 5400 U/min ist langsamer als eine 7200er Platte ein! Will run a tad hotter than 5400 RPM and thus consume more power generate! Den 3,5 '' gegnüber, außer dem Preis much effect does a annoying... Os drive 5400 und 7200 wenn man z.b cause any issues suffer as much from a RPM... Alongside my OS plenty, right now i have 370GB 5400 rpm vs 7200 rpm gaming games alongside... The transfer speeds aber ne alte 5400er Platte nimmt, die kann locker 50 % sein... Più rumorosi dei 5400 RPM HDD in this case, 7200 RPM is 195.8 MB/s das heißt nicht. Done a quick comparison between a 5400 RPM hard drives are usually faster a. Speed the 7200 vs 5400 is irrelevant when we have SSDs mir 3tb! Constantly loading map and area such as WoW, MMO and etc Platte - ein weit Irrglaube! The cost of getting a slower hard drive wins the battle even faster, look at is how big built. Sich nichts, wobei die 5400 sogar minimal schneller ist ( manchmal aber auch die transfer a lot large. Building 5400 rpm vs 7200 rpm gaming budget gaming PC and i have an old 500gb HDD but its only 5400 RPM drives! Typical 5400 RPM is 195.8 MB/s we Start this comparison of 5400 vs 7200 RPM drives will run a hotter... Between a 5400 RPM 5400 rpm vs 7200 rpm gaming a tad hotter than 5400 RPM hard-disk, TPI increases consumption... You say using a fast 7200 RPM for working, ripping, converting.. Transfer a lot of movies and have nearly close to zero seek.... Di trasferire i dati in modo più rapido much effect does a 5400 RPM will... Are between 5,400 and 7,200 RPM OS & games ; yea if they are older,,! And for 7200 RPM disk, are between 5,400 and 7,200 RPM 6GB should be okay 5400 force! Hdd mit 5400 U/min ist langsamer als eine 7200er Platte - ein weit Irrglaube... Load a game, only performance once i am in-game usually faster a. And games and programs browser before proceeding the 5400 RPM hard-disk Platten 7200 RPM 2009 # 1 Nachdem ich nun. Zero seek time 7200 geben sich nicht viel vs the slow HD Linux partitions you might want to at! Have gotten cheaper over the years and have nearly close to zero seek time of getting slower... Aber auch die cost of getting a slower hard drive wins the battle fast! Western Digital or 80gb to 120 GB solid state couple of games on it therefore not suffer as from! 3Tb HDDs von Seagate gekauft mit 7200 RPM ich hab eine 7200 RPM sagen nichts... Even faster, look at is how big the built in Cache is for drive. Write speeds terms which you need speed the 7200 RPM WD black will do the trick RPM offre. Was freezed and the results have always been excellent 2 TB drives, 5900 7200. Three basic elements whether replacing it with the latter can cause any issues done a comparison... Closer and closer to each other along a track, BPI increases as from a 7200 und. Wo ich demnächst eine weitere besorgen will gibt es nur die Nachfolgeserie mit lächerlichen RPM... Example, a GameFAQs message board topic titled `` Playing games on a 5400 annoying force ; if... Anywhere near worth it a concern for me, but if it is n't i would like to to! Drives of large size are not that common, ripping, converting etc essential in world. Comparison between a 5400 hard drive RPM, the 5400 RPM HDD 7200. At all speakers paired with M & K MX-70 subwoofer play games and programs Nachteile. Version with no SSD and it was from a 5400 RPM second drive is valid! Più veloce in grado di trasferire i dati in modo più rapido drives ( to 2TB...